Florida Attorney General Speaks Out Against Marriage Equality

Alan R. Burton Attorney at Law

Marriage equality has been a hot topic in Florida ever since a same-sex couple requested that a Florida family court approve their agreed-upon divorce settlement. The couple had been legally and validly married in Massachusetts, however moved to Florida shortly thereafter. You must file for divorce in the state in which you are a resident, so they filed for divorce in Florida.

Florida, however, has a constitutional provision that only recognizes marriage as between a man and a woman. Because the state does not recognize that a same-sex marriage exists, the court decided there was no marriage to dissolve and therefore refused to grant them a divorce. They would be unable to file for divorce in Massachusetts unless one of them moved back there for at least one year, an option the couple states is impossible because of professional obligations.

The couple is appealing the decision and the Florida Supreme Court will examine the issue, as well as the validity of the constitutional amendment banning gay marriage.

Arguments in the Case

Pam Bondi is the Attorney General for the state of Florida and is defending the state’s constitutional ban on same-sex marriage in the case. Bondi has argued that recognizing same-sex marriages from other states would be disruptive and that it would “impose significant public harm.” Specifically, Bondi has indicated that same-sex couples do not provide the same stability or enduring family units. Ironically, Bondi herself has been divorced two times and is currently on her third marriage.

LGBT rights groups such as the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and Safeguarding American Values for Everyone (SAVE) have criticized Bondi for her illogical and false arguments regarding the link between same-sex marriage and unstable households for children. SAVE called her reasoning nothing but “discriminatory rhetoric” and not a valid legal argument. Instead, the couple’s attorney and rights activists have pointed out that many same-sex couples raise biological children of at least one of the spouses, so procreation is not a persuasive reason to prohibit same-sex marriage.

Bondi also argues that recognizing same-sex marriages from other states would cause problems for the state’s pension and health insurance programs. However, human rights groups counter that the harm to same-sex couples who are denied such benefits far outweighs the inconvenience to the state of adapting its systems.

Courts in numerous states are questioning existing bans and limits on same-sex marriage in recent months. Federal judges in Ohio and Kentucky recently ordered that out-of-state same-sex marriages should be recognized within the states, and a federal appeals court will be ruling on a number of gay marriage cases.

As the decisions involving same-sex marriage keep coming both in Florida and across the United States, the scope of family laws will likely change significantly, bringing numerous issues related to same-sex marriage into the courts.

Alan Burton is an experienced family law attorney who stays up to date on all changes in the law and knows how to handle a wide variety of family-related cases. If you have any type of family law concern, contact our office for help today.

Client Reviews

Alan R. Burton is a good human being but truly a great lawyer. Alan R. Burton took my very weak case but with his dedication and smartness Alan R. Burton ended up winning it for me and most important Alan R. Burton won the case with 0% tolerance for lies and 100% for truth. I’m simply convinced with...

Amer A.

"Alan Burton represented me on a tough child support case. He was extremely professional, aggressive and ethical in the courtroom. He is very honest and knowledgeable. I would highly recommend him for any case, no questions asked. Thank you Mr. Burton for all of your help and support through this...

Abigail A.

"As a single working mother of two young children, I totally appreciated Alan's flexibility to E mail and to converse by phone. There were times I could only respond or ask questions regarding my case well after 6 P.M. and Alan always made himself available to suit my schedule. Alan is a single dad...

Stephanie C.

"I give great pleasure in writing this review for Mr. Alan Burton. He was a tremendous help in resolving my foreign divorce/child custody case. Very competent, knowledgeable and always available; day and night. I am located in the Middle East and had a very complicated divorce/child custody case...

David A.

"As any devoted parent who loves their children, imagine the thought of your children being abducted by another parent. The feeling of not knowing if you will ever get them back, the anxiety of court proceedings, and a possible International custody battle. This is something I would never want any...

Stefan B.

Get in Touch

  1. 1 Free Consultation
  2. 2 40 Years of Experience
  3. 3 Speak Directly to an Attorney
Fill out the contact form or call us at (954) 229-1660 to schedule your free consultation.

Leave Us a Message